Experimental investigation of the effectiveness of problem-based learning

2009 2009

Other formats: Order a copy

Abstract (summary)

Problem-based learning (PBL), although increasingly popular, is expensive and labor-intensive to implement. Research evidence has not yet established that PBL's benefits are worth its cost.

Studies of PBL conducted in naturalistic educational environments are typically so loosely controlled as to make interpretation problematic. Problems with these studies include self-selection to conditions, uncontrolled variation across conditions, and multidimensional treatment conditions.

Two tightly controlled experiments were conducted in a college classroom setting. In both, a crossed design, with randomized assignment and control over potential confounds, was employed. Two equivalent college classes of a science course taught by the same instructor were compared in their learning of two concepts of equivalent difficulty over a period of four weeks. In Study 1, class A learned the first concept via lecture/discussion and the second concept via PBL. Class B learned the first concept via PBL and the second via lecture/discussion. Students' performance was assessed 4 times, immediately after each concept was introduced (at weeks two and four) and again at weeks 9, 13 and 16. Results indicated students' superior mastery of the concept learned via PBL in terms of understanding, integration and application.

Study 2 examined the sources of PBL's effectiveness, specifically whether the characteristic feature of social collaboration is a necessary component of PBL. This was accomplished using the same design, procedures and instruments employed in Study 1 but comparing a group engaged in individual PBL experience vs. a group engaged in the more typical small-group PBL format. Results indicated that collaboration is not an essential component of PBL, as revealed by a lack of a significant difference in students' performance across these two conditions. Performance in both conditions remained superior to that in the Lecture/discussion condition.

The results of this research have the potential to be drawn on as a basis for decision-making in educational policy and practice, achieving the desirable and currently much-discussed goal of basing such decisions on rigorous empirical evidence.

Indexing (details)

Educational psychology;
Experimental psychology;
Cognitive psychology;
Effectiveness studies;
Problem solving;
0525: Educational psychology
0623: Experimental psychology
0633: Cognitive psychology
Identifier / keyword
Education; Psychology; Collaborative learning; Experimental study; Higher education; Learning; Problem-based learning; Social collaboration in PBL
Experimental investigation of the effectiveness of problem-based learning
Pease, Maria Angelica
Number of pages
Publication year
Degree date
School code
DAI-A 70/08, Dissertation Abstracts International
Place of publication
Ann Arbor
Country of publication
United States
Kuhn, Deanna
Columbia University
University location
United States -- New York
Source type
Dissertations & Theses
Document type
Dissertation/thesis number
ProQuest document ID
Database copyright ProQuest LLC; ProQuest does not claim copyright in the individual underlying works.
Document URL
Access the complete full text

You can get the full text of this document if it is part of your institution's ProQuest subscription.

Try one of the following:

  • Connect to ProQuest through your library network and search for the document from there.
  • Request the document from your library.
  • Go to the ProQuest login page and enter a ProQuest or My Research username / password.