Content area
Full Text
The last decade has seen a veritable resurgence of the theme of habit in philosophical and critical debates. While for decades the preference had been accorded to either the active forces of will and desire or the contingency and abruptness of the Event, thinkers have recently come back to habit from different paths and perspectives (Bennett et al.; Sparrow and Hutchinson; Carlisle). The polarization of attention around the theme of habit almost seems to mirror the veritable explosion of the discourse on habit which took place about two centuries ago. Even though the philosophical reflection on habit can be traced at least as far back as Aristotle it was at the end of the eighteenth century and in the early nineteenth century that the theme of habit, as asserted in the entry habitude of the Encyclopédie Philosophique Universelle, became "a new philosophical challenge" as an effect of "the refusal of innate ideas; the sensualist project deriving the modes of understanding from experience (generally exterior experience); the refusal, finally, of Hume's category of causality and its reduction to pure habit" (1108; my translation). In France, habit was an extremely popular theme among spiritualist or proto-spiritualist philosophers such as Maine de Biran and Ravaisson, who considered it the bridge between spirit and matter. In Germany, Hegel tackled the problem of habit in The Philosophy of Right, making it the basis of custom on which a true ethical life is grounded. In Italy, reprehensible antisocial habits fell under the magnifying glass of the Turin positivist school and became a pivotal part of Lombroso's analysis of the criminal mind.
In the English speaking world, Samuel Butler (1835-1902) was probably the most original contributor to the debate on habit in the second part of the nineteenth century. He used the notion of habit to challenge Charles Darwin's theory of evolution, conceiving habit as the channel through which unconscious memory can be passed down from one generation to the next, preserved in the experience of the species and its determination to evolve into more complex forms (see Willey). Samuel Butler's theories have been widely disregarded among professional philosophers, because of his idiosyncratic and counter-intuitive use of the notion of habit and due to the fact that his arguments have often been...